Chronic Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) Insufficiency
Chronic anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) insufficiency happens when the ACL has been torn and hasn’t been repaired, or if it didn’t heal properly. Over time, the lack of a functional ACL can make the knee unstable, meaning it can give out or feel weak during physical activities like running, jumping, or even walking on uneven ground (Figure 1). Activities that involve turning or suddenly changing direction will often cause ACL deficient knee to feel unstable. People with chronic ACL insufficiency may also develop pain, swelling, or arthritis in the knee because the unstable joint wears down faster. This condition can make it hard to stay active and might require surgery or special therapy to improve knee function and stability.

Conditions Commonly Associated with ACL Insufficiency
Patients with chronic anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) insufficiency often have other problems with their knee. These can include damage to the cartilage, like the meniscus, which cushions the knee, and arthritis, which happens when the cartilage covering the knee joint wears down over time, causing pain and stiffness. The muscles around the knee may also become weaker because they aren’t used as much to avoid pain or instability. Sometimes, other ligaments in the knee can get injured or stretched out from the extra strain of trying to keep the knee stable. These issues can make it even harder to move and do normal activities.
Diagnosing Anterior Cruciate Ligament Insufficiency
Chronic anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) insufficiency is diagnosed through a combination of the patient’s symptoms and a physical exam. People with this condition often complain of knee instability, pain, and swelling, especially during physical activities like running or jumping. They might also feel like their knee is giving way or buckling under them. During the exam, a doctor will check for signs of weakness in the knee muscles, look for swelling of the knee joint, and test the knee’s range of motion. Special tests, like checking if the shin bone moves too much (anterior draw or Lachman test), can help determine if the ACL is not functioning properly. Sometimes, doctors will use an MRI to confirm the ACL injury and assess the extent of damage within the knee joint in more detail.
Treatment of Chronic ACL Insufficiency
Chronic anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) insufficiency is usually treated with a combination of therapy and, in many cases, surgery. Physical therapy is important to strengthen the muscles around the knee, improve stability, and reduce pain. In some patients the use of a special knee brace may improve their symptoms.
If the knee is still unstable or the symptoms are severe, surgery may be needed to repair or replace the torn ACL with a new ligament. If additional damage to the knee joint, such as a torn meniscus, is identified during surgery it will also be treated. After surgery, recovery involves more physical therapy to help the knee heal, regain strength, and return to normal activities. Some people may also need to adjust their activities to avoid putting too much strain on the knee in the long term.
Long-Term Risks of ACL Insufficiency
Chronic anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) insufficiency can lead to long-term problems, especially if it isn’t treated properly. Over time, the knee can become unstable and more likely to get injured again, which can make activities like sports or even walking harder. The instability can also cause extra wear and tear on the cartilage, which may lead to arthritis, causing pain and stiffness in the knee. Since the muscles around the knee may be weaker, it can make it harder to control the movement of the joint. All of these issues can make the knee less functional and affect a person’s quality of life in the long run.
Edited by Amari Eubnanks and Stephen Pinney MD June 14th, 2025