Chronic Rotator Cuff Tears
Introduction
A chronic rotator cuff tear is a gradual wearing or tearing of the tendons that help move and stabilize the shoulder (Figure 1). Unlike an acute tear that happens suddenly after an injury, a chronic tear develops slowly over time. It starts in a tendon already weakened by rotator cuff tendonitis or age-related degeneration. These tears are more common in older adults and can occur with mild trauma or even normal daily activities. Some patients with chronic rotator cuff tears have no symptoms, or only mild symptoms. However, common symptoms include shoulder pain, weakness, and difficulty lifting the arm or reaching overhead. Some people also notice night pain that makes it hard to sleep on the affected shoulder.

Diagnosing a Chronic Rotator Cuff Tear
A doctor diagnoses a chronic rotator cuff tear by taking a careful history and performing a physical exam. They may ask about how long the shoulder has been painful and whether it affects daily activities. On exam, the doctor will check range of motion and strength using specific tests, such as the empty can test (for the supraspinatus tendon) or the external rotation test (for the infraspinatus tendon). Imaging studies help confirm the diagnosis. X-rays can show bone changes or narrowing of the space above the shoulder joint, while ultrasound or MRI scans provide detailed images of the tendons to show the size and location of the tear.
Non-Surgical Treatment of a Chronic Rotator Cuff Tear
Most chronic rotator cuff tears can be managed initially without surgery. Conservative treatment aims to reduce pain and improve shoulder strength and function. Treatment may include rest, activity modification, anti-inflammatory medications, and physical therapy. Physical therapy focuses on improving shoulder motion, strengthening the remaining intact muscles, and improving posture. Corticosteroid injections may be used for persistent pain but are typically reserved for short-term relief. Many patients—especially older adults with lower physical demands—do well with these treatments and can maintain good shoulder function.
Surgical Treatment of Chronic Rotator Cuff Tears
Surgery to repair the rotator cuff may be considered when non-surgical treatments fail to relieve pain or when weakness limits daily activities. The goal of surgery is to repair the torn tendon, restore shoulder strength, and prevent further degeneration. Repair is often done arthroscopically, using a small camera and instruments inserted through tiny incisions. The surgeon reattaches the torn tendon to the bone with sutures and anchors. In some cases where the tear is too large or the tendon tissue is poor quality, other procedures such as a tendon or soft-tissue transfer, or a reverse shoulder replacement may be necessary.
Prognosis
The outlook for patients with a chronic rotator cuff tear depends on the size of the tear, tendon quality, and the patient’s age and activity level. Many patients respond well to non-surgical care and maintain good shoulder function. When surgery is required, most people regain significant strength and reduced pain after rehabilitation. However, healing may be slower than in acute tears, and very large or old tears may not fully recover normal strength. Although uncommon, some patients with large, untreated rotator cuff tears can develop a special type of shoulder arthritis called rotator cuff arthropathy, where the shoulder joint becomes unstable and painful over time.
Summary
A chronic rotator cuff tear happens slowly, often in older people whose have had long-standing rotator cuff tendonitis causing the shoulder tendons have weakened over time. A chronic rotator cuff tear may causes pain, weakness, and trouble lifting the arm. Doctors use exams and scans like MRI to find the tear. Many people get better with rest, therapy, and medication, but some may need surgery. With proper care, most shoulders improve, though large untreated tears can sometimes lead to a type of shoulder arthritis called rotator cuff arthropathy.
Edited by Stephen Pinney MD, July 26th 2026.